Harvinder Singh, a deportee, claimed in an interview that he and others were handcuffed and shackled during the 40-hour journey.The claim that EAM S. Jaishankar contradicted the government’s fact-check is misleading. While Jaishankar acknowledged that the use of restraints is part of standard deportation procedures, this does not directly oppose the PIB’s fact-check, which refuted exaggerated claims circulating online.

Claim:
External Affairs Minister (EAM) S. Jaishankar contradicted the government’s fact-check regarding Indian deportees being handcuffed during their deportation from the US.

Verdict:
Misleading


The Claim:
A claim circulated on social media and news platforms suggesting that EAM S. Jaishankar contradicted the government’s official fact-check by acknowledging in the Rajya Sabha that Indian immigrants deported from the US may have been “restrained” using handcuffs and shackles. This appeared to conflict with the Press Information Bureau’s (PIB) statement, which labeled as FAKE the claims that deported Indian migrants were handcuffed and chained during their flight.

The confusion arose following the deportation of 104 Indian immigrants via a US military aircraft, with allegations from some deportees claiming they were restrained for extended periods.


https://twitter.com/PIBFactCheck/status/1887148007092809815?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1887148007092809815%7Ctwgr%5Ee77cc6307fa5479b71dbbaa0bf7cd44394c1c66a%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.livemint.com%2Fpolitics%2Fdid-jaishankar-contradict-govt-factcheck-in-rajya-sabha-what-eam-said-on-illegal-indian-deportees-being-handcuffed-11738838943935.html

Fact-Check Analysis:
To determine if Jaishankar’s remarks contradicted the government’s position, we analyzed both the minister’s statements and the official fact-check from PIB.

  1. Official Statements or Evidence:
    • Jaishankar’s Statement: In the Rajya Sabha, Jaishankar stated, “The standard operating procedure for deportation by aircraft provides for the use of restraints. However, we have been informed that women and children are not restrained.” He also mentioned that deportees are temporarily unrestrained during toilet breaks if needed.
    • PIB Fact-Check: The PIB categorically dismissed claims circulating on social media, stating, “The claim that Indian migrants were deported with hands and legs cuffed with chains is FAKE.” This statement targeted specific images and exaggerated claims being spread online.
  2. Additional Findings:
    • Deportee Testimony: Harvinder Singh, a deportee, claimed in an interview that he and others were handcuffed and shackled during the 40-hour journey.
    • US Border Patrol Confirmation: The US Border Patrol shared a video showing deportees with visible restraints, confirming that some level of restraint was used.
    • Standard Deportation Practices: Restraints are often used during deportations to maintain security, as per international aviation security protocols, especially on military aircraft.
https://twitter.com/USBPChief/status/1886946028185682347?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1886946028185682347%7Ctwgr%5Ee77cc6307fa5479b71dbbaa0bf7cd44394c1c66a%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.livemint.com%2Fpolitics%2Fdid-jaishankar-contradict-govt-factcheck-in-rajya-sabha-what-eam-said-on-illegal-indian-deportees-being-handcuffed-11738838943935.html

Context:
The deportation involved 104 Indian immigrants who were flown back to Amritsar on a US military aircraft, with many claiming harsh treatment during transit. The opposition raised concerns in Parliament, demanding clarity on the deportation process and the treatment of Indian citizens abroad.

While the PIB’s fact-check focused on dismissing exaggerated claims about severe mistreatment, Jaishankar’s acknowledgment reflected procedural realities rather than contradicting the fact-check. His statement highlighted that restraints are standard in such deportations, but not in the extreme form claimed on social media.


Conclusion:
The claim that EAM S. Jaishankar contradicted the government’s fact-check is misleading. While Jaishankar acknowledged that the use of restraints is part of standard deportation procedures, this does not directly oppose the PIB’s fact-check, which refuted exaggerated claims circulating online. The minister provided procedural clarity, while the fact-check addressed misinformation about the severity of the restraints.

Verdict: Misleading


81 thoughts on “FACT CHECK: Did External Affairs Minister Jaishankar Contradict Government’s Fact-Check on Indian Deportees?”
  1. The bet slip keeps the selected event, market, odds, and stake together before confirmation. Australian customers
    can use AUD stakes and review the market rules before confirming a bet.

    Our sports section supports pre-match and live markets where events are listed.
    The registration form should contain accurate personal information because the same details are used during payment and identity checks.

    Our Payid Casino Welcome Bonus includes a
    100% match bonus up to $500 and 100 free spins on the first deposit.

  2. Der Anbieter ist inzwischen im Kassenbereich vieler Casinos verfügbar, so dass es meist kein Problem ist, im Casino mit Trustly zu zahlen. Online Casino Trustly Einzahlungen sind sofort verfügbar, Auszahlungen oft innerhalb weniger Stunden. Wie genau das funktioniert kann in unserem Guide zu https://mrsurepunters.ng/forum/topic/trustly-casinos-im-vergleich-sicher-und-schnell-zahlen/ Casinos ohne Registrierung nachgelesen werden.

  3. The casino features certified online pokies with strong RTP percentages, generous welcome bonuses, and fast payout processing. Despite the low entry barrier, the casino doesn’t compromise on quality, offering over 3,000 games from reputable providers. Customer support via live chat responds within minutes, though you’ll need to log in to access it. What sets Lucky Dreams apart is its commitment to quick payouts. Neosurf is very secure because it uses prepaid vouchers, meaning you never share your bank or credit card information with the casino. Select any casino from our list that supports Neosurf to deposit instantly and start playing.

    References: https://ibescore.com/forum/topic/neosurf-accepted-casinos-australia-key-facts-fees/

  4. Wager the Bonus & Deposit amount 20 times on Slots to Cashout. Wager the Bonus & Deposit amount 25 times on Slots to Cashout. Wager the Bonus & Deposit amount 35 times on Slots to Cashout. Thus, they would provide their personal information and bank account number, as well as the information of the recipient, and give the telegraph service the cash amount. Some offshore casinos support Venmo transactions through third-party services like MatchPay, which connects players for peer-to-peer payments. Visa and Mastercard debit cards are commonly supported, although individual banks may decline gambling-related transactions.

    References: https://ewicare.com/forum/tema/choosing-wire-transfer-casino-bonus-australia-made-simple/

  5. And although online PayID pokies don’t allow withdrawals via this method, they are still popular because they are convenient, impose virtually no frames on bonuses, and are accessible to everyone. Among the six casinos with PayID in this guide, Wild Tokyo accepts deposits from AU$15 while the remaining five — HellSpin, Dudespin, RollingSlots, Slotsgem, and Dragonia — all start at AU$20. If you care more about simplicity and minimum deposit accessibility, Wild Tokyo’s AU$15 entry point makes it the most bankroll-friendly option for new payid pokies real money players entering the market.

    References: https://forum.okehampton.org/d/17-payid-pokies-facebook-real-money-no-deposit-bonus-for-aussie-players

  6. Some Australians use prepaid vouchers like this https://forum.streamlive.hr/public/d/27-trusted-neosurf-casinos-australia-safety-payment-guide keep online spending separate from their main bank account. What many players like about using this payment option is that there are usually no fees on transactions, including when you purchase the vouchers from retailers. Neosurf lets casino players deposit using a prepaid voucher instead of entering bank or card details at the cashier. Having a few spins on online pokies is an Australian pastime, and you’ll find thousands of titles at the best Neosurf online casinos.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!